2016: When young mother Sherri Papini vanishes a mile from her rural California home during a morning jog, all eyes are on her husband Keith. But as the frantic search to find her makes headlines around the world, investigators are dumbfounded.

After Sherri is discovered on Thanksgiving morning, she describes a violent abduction and nightmarish captivity. When her account leads to search for two Hispanic woman, the public demands answers while her family retreats from the public eye.

2020: As Keith struggles to support Sherri's trauma and rebuild their family, an unexpected call from law enforcement leads to new revelations that turn their world upside down - yet again.