Elmer's transition out of the Amish leads to an unsavory addiction. Laurie struggles with the pressures of converting to Orthodox Judaism. Ashley sets out to ease the tension between her conservative Catholic family and her Muslim husband.

Kris, a Pentecostal preachers' son, grapples with his family's disapproval of his Muslim girlfriend's religion. A trip to the wig store has Laurie questioning her commitment to Orthodox Judaism. Ashley makes a risky decision that could blow up in her face.

Lindsey takes drastic measures to stop Elmer's porn habit. Eli's mom questions Laurie's dedication to Orthodox Judaism. Ashley's plan to bring Mohammed and her family together backfires. Tensions rise when Kris's dad pushes salvation onto Lensa.

Mohammed confronts Ashley's sister. Eli and Laurie butt heads when Eli realizes Laurie won't wear her Star of David necklace. Lindsey hatches a plan for Elmer to make amends with his family. When Kris's dad's sermon singles her out, Lensa storms out of church service.

Ashley finally confronts Mohammed's twin brother. Kris's dad pushes Lensa too far. Lindsey and Elmer head into Amish country to reconcile with his family but when word gets out, things take a turn for the worse.

Mohammed gives Ashley an ultimatum. Tensions threaten to boil over at Eli and Laurie's housewarming party. Still dealing with his family's rejection, Elmer regresses back to his Amish ways leaving Lindsey questioning if he's ready to be a parent. Kris is faced with a life-changing decision. 

Ashley and Mohammed seek marriage counseling. Laurie receives upsetting news from her sister. Elmer and Lindsey host a gender reveal party. Lensa confronts Kris after discovering troubling messages on his phone.

Lindsey makes a shocking discovery about Elmer. Laurie's conversion hits a roadblock. Lensa makes a jaw-dropping decision. Ashley doubts whether converting to Islam is right for her.