Six outsiders flee the chaos of modern society for a chance to join the Amish community, but harsh rules and culture shock ignite instant conflict. With both sides refusing to bend, tensions erupt into a standoff.

The English outsiders face the realities of Amish hard work, while a secret from someone's past threatens their place in the community.

A sudden departure rattles the group. Esmeralda faces harsh judgment during her Amish makeover, and Kendra's heartbreak pushes James to break one of the biggest Amish rules.

Esmeralda confronts her fears about identity amidst her Amish transformation. Aaron struggles without his hearing aids, and Allen plays matchmaker for Billie Jo. Then a shocking return leaves everyone on edge.

The Bishop hears firsthand accounts exposing hidden truths unfolding within his community. Cousins James and Emma reveal a shocking secret at a party. Matt and Kendra risk everything as they set off to break one of the Amish's most sacred rules.

A tangled love connection sparks jealousy and suspicion; a disappointing update puts the Bishop's mission in jeopardy; mounting tensions threaten the standing of both the Amish and the English within the community.

Judah's mother arrives unannounced with intentions to bring him home. As Reckoning Day approaches, mysterious symptoms send BJ to the hospital.

On the eve of Reckoning Day, Judah comes out as bisexual, surprising many. The English stand before the congregation and submit themselves to the church's decision—whether they will be welcomed into the Amish church or formally rejected.